See the Northern Lights
Obviously – this is what you came for, right?!? The Northern Lights (Aurora Borealis) are one of the 7 Natural Wonders of the world for good reason. See my notes about best timing and pro tips for the best ways to guarantee you'll really see them with your own eyes, not just through a camera lens.
Plan to go out for at least 3 nights from 10pm to 2am, ideally with a tour group that can take you to a good viewing spot and provide a warming hut, hot beverages, and a fire when there isn't much to look at.
If you use Northern Tales, the cost for 3 nights of lodging + viewing for 2 people sharing a room is ~$600 USD per person ($200/person/night). That includes airport pick up and drop off, transportation to and from the warming huts in a bus or van, and 4 hours of viewing for 3 nights. Honestly, totally worth it!!! You can also rent warm winter gear (jackets, boots, pants, gloves) if you need it for $40-$50 USD/person/day.